I recently read a scathing attack on the lyrics of Extreme’s 1993 hit ‘More Than Words’. Seems like this criticism is coming a little late to the game (by, say, almost 20 years) but can you really disagree that this power ballad played fast and loose with the rules of grammar?
Saying I love you
Is not the words I want to hear from you
It’s not that I want you
Not to say, but if you only knew
How easy it would be to show me how you feel
More than words is all you have to do to make it real
Then you wouldn’t have to say that you love me
‘Cause I’d already know
But does a love song really need perfect syntax to be meaningful? Go back to The Delfonics ‘Lalala Means I love You’ or ‘Be Bop a Lula, She’s My Baby’ (covered by everyone from The Everly Brothers to The Beatles to Queen). Or more recent offerings, like Outkast’s ‘Hey Ya’. Is it the richest writing since Shakespeare composed his sonnets? Absolutely not.
Heeeyyy… Yaaaaaaa.. (OHH OH)
Heeyy Yaaaaaaaa.. (OHH OH)
Heeeyyy… Yaaaaaaa.. (Don’t want to meet your daddy, OHH OH)
Heeyy Yaaaaaaaa.. (Just want you in my Caddy OHH OH)
Heeeyyy… Yaaaaaaa.. (OHH OH, don’t want to meet yo’ mama OHH OH)
Heeyy Yaaaaaaaa.. (Just wan’t to make you cumma OHH OH)
But does it make you want to grab your lady and hit the dance floor? Heck yeah.
It seems to me that the best love songs allow you to project yourself – and your lover – fully into the lyrics so that it seems like the song could have been written exclusively for you. The more ridiculous the lyrics, the easier it is for you to drift away into a fantasy world where your girlfriend is ‘my brown-eyed girl’ or you decide that ‘everything I do, I do it for you’.
There are love songs out there that paint a more complex picture of people and relationships – the highs and lows, the challenges, the imperfections and annoyances – but they never seem to go down as the iconic love songs.
For the record, our favorite love song is ‘Luna’ by the Smashing Pumpkins. It was the first song Melissa and I realized we both loved. It was the first dance at our wedding. And a lot of the lyrics make absolutely no sense, whatsoever.
What moonsongs
Do you sing your babies?
What sunshine do you bring?
Who belongs
Who decides who’s crazy
Who rights wrongs where others cling?
I have to admit I have no idea what Billy Corgan is talking about. I’ve never sung a moonsong to Melissa.. I don’t right wrongs, even where others cling. But there’s a beautiful, clear simplicity to the last couples of verses of the song:
I’m in love with you
So in love
I’m in love with you
With you
I’m in love with you
I’m in love with you
So in love
I’m in love with you
I’m so in love
I’m in love with you
That’s a sentiment that’s easy to understand and remains very true.
OK, your turn. What are your favorite love songs? Is the song honest? Is a love song any less valid because it’s complete nonsense?













